LOCAL MUSINGS - Let’s not import the disease
By ‘The Gherk’

The man arrested over the attack on Helen Haines has now been publicly identified as Brendan Nugent, 43, from Tarrawingee. And before everyone immediately reaches for the ideological jersey, can we please resist doing the American thing for a day. Because within hours of the attack, people had already decided who he must be. One Nation cooker. Radical leftist. Pro-Hamas extremist. Anti-Israel activist. Environmental radical. Pick your tribe, select your villain, screenshot accordingly.
The emerging picture is messier. Nugent had previously been involved in anti-logging environmental campaigning. His social media history includes hostility towards Labor, support for some positions, increasingly conspiratorial material and some genuinely extreme rhetoric about Israel, Gaza and the Houthis.
He had also, rather inconveniently for anyone hoping for a neat partisan story, previously supported Helen Haines herself, shared her material and praised her position on multiple fronts. Police still have not publicly established a motive.
We are becoming so tribal that the first instinct after something horrific happens is no longer: What happened? It’s: Which team gets blamed? And anyone trying to turn this into a partisan victory lap should be ashamed of themselves.
A woman has been seriously injured. Police are still working through motive, evidence, online material, witness accounts and everything else that goes into understanding what happened.
This is not the moment to rummage through someone’s social media history looking for the perfect ideological label so you can yell: “SEE. THEIR SIDE.”
That instinct is part of the problem. If your first response to political violence is relief that the alleged attacker can be assigned to the opposing tribe, you’re not defending democracy but treating it like State of Origin.
We’ve watched this happen in the United States for years. Every shooting, riot, attack or act of political violence becomes an ideological sporting event before investigators have even packed away the evidence markers. Everyone races to identify the perpetrator’s politics because if he belongs to their side, it proves the other side is evil. If he belongs to "our side", suddenly context becomes extremely important. We cannot import that disease here.
This bloke does not represent environmentalists. He does not represent ordinary Australians. Just as the most cooked Facebook uncle does not represent every ordinary Australian.
Extremists are unwell. Left-wing cooker. Right-wing cooker. Religious cooker. Nationalist cooker. Anti-government cooker.
I’m sure somewhere out there someone has managed to become a centrist cooker and is currently screaming about the Reserve Bank from inside a Mazda CX-5. The ideology changes. The pattern doesn’t.
A person disappears further into a world where every institution is corrupt, every disagreement is existential, every opponent is evil and every algorithm keeps handing them another piece of content confirming that they alone have seen through the matrix.
Fear becomes anger > Anger becomes identity > Identity becomes grievance... And eventually somebody decides normal democratic disagreement is no longer enough.
That is where we should be looking. Not at each other. At the people and systems making enormous amounts of money by keeping us frightened, furious and permanently convinced that half the country is our enemy.
Political grifters know fear converts into votes and donations. Influencers know telling you the country is being stolen from you performs better than saying your neighbour probably just disagrees about tax policy. And every day the temperature inches upward.
The attack on Helen Haines should not become another excuse for Australians to divide themselves into camps and start hurling collective blame at one another.
It should frighten us into doing the opposite. Get angrier at the people monetising division. Get angrier at the algorithms feeding vulnerable people increasingly extreme rubbish. Get angrier at political actors who know exactly what they are doing when they convince followers that opponents are traitors, enemies or existential threats. And spend a little less time hating the person across the fence because they voted differently.
Helen Haines is not a prop in anyone’s culture war. Most Australians are not extremists. Most Australians are not cookers.
Most Australians are just trying to get through the week, pay the rent / mortgage, get the kids to school and occasionally argue about whether a tram counts as being on the road. That enormous middle is worth protecting.
We’ve watched other countries travel down this road, we don’t have to follow them.






Comments